Banana Cream Pie Recipe

Banana Cream Pie

banana cream pie slice

I love, love, love pies! There’s something about crust filled with yummy things that just appeal to me (to the cost of my hips). When I first came to the US, I was amazed by the variety of pies and I just couldn’t get enough of them.

I discovered banana cream pie when an acquaintance who attended the Hawaii Writing Project with me brought them one day to share. They were so delightful that I had to get the recipe. She generously shared it with me.

Testing, Testing

I baked this banana cream pie recently because I’m testing out the microwave/convection oven that came with our house. I figured if the crust didn’t turn out, it wouldn’t be as big a loss as a whole cake. From my research into other similar types ovens plus all the help I had gotten from some of you, I plunged ahead with this pie as my first bake.

And it turned out pretty good despite the oven not coming with any manual at all. The crust did bake up brown but I think I still need to work out the timing and temps a bit more to get it perfect. For a first attempt, I was quite happy.

I also chose to bake a banana cream pie because I am now in a land of plentiful bananas. Local bananas are so varied and delicious that we are eating a bunch or two a week. For this pie, I used Pisang Rastali/Kering, a banana that is very similar to the apple bananas you find in Hawaii. They are creamy but have a slight tart apple finish. Simply delicious—my absolute favorite variety!

Lessons Learned

The first time I tried to bake a banana cream pie, I must have had beginner’s luck because everything turned out really well. There have been a few times since then that the egg paste curdled when I mixed it into the milk. I suspect that the milk was too hot when I added the egg yolks (I get impatient and crank up the heat sometimes) and that is what caused the curdling. So make sure you keep the heat on the milk low when you’re adding the egg paste. Don’t let the milk come to a boil! But if you do get some curdling, all is not lost—just strain the pudding before filling the pie.

The recipe for the crust makes a really flaky and tender crust. It’s not the most flavorful crust because it doesn’t have any butter in it. But since the banana and the pudding is very flavorful already, this crust is a nice complement. If you want more flavor, feel free to substitute butter for the shortening, but you will lose the flaky texture you get from the shortening. Maybe next time, I will try it with half butter and half shortening. Anyway, if you are making this dough as it is written, be sure to chill the dough first so that the crust won’t shrink back too much while baking.

This recipe bakes up enough crust and filling to make two pies. And I recommend making two as they disappear very quickly. I served this at a church small group meeting and when the evening was done, I only had a quarter of one pie left to take home as leftovers.

Banana Cream Pie Recipe

(makes 2 pies)

Pie Crust Ingredients:
1 1/2 cup all-purpose flour
1 cup crisco (I used a butter blend here in Malaysia)
2/3 cup all-purpose flour
1/2 cup milk

banana cream pie crust dough and batter

Pie Crust Method:
1. Rub ingredients A together to form a shaggy dough in a medium bowl. Yes, I know it’s quite a bit of fat but you can always add more flour later if it’s too wet. It’s the fat that makes this pie crust flaky and tender.
2. Mix ingredients B together to form a paste in another bowl.
3. Add B to A and mix gently with a spatula until it forms a dough. If it’s too wet, add more flour to the dough to get a nice soft dough. Don’t overwork the dough; the crust will be more tender and flaky the less it is worked.

banana cream pie crust dough

4. Form two balls, cover them in plastic wrap and chill in the fridge for at least an hour.

banana cream pie crust dough ball

5. Preheat oven to 400 F (210 C).
6. Roll out your dough into a round, about 1/8 inch thick, dusting with flour to keep it from sticking. Place dough rounds on your pie pan and press into pan and crimp edges to the side of the pan. Dock with a fork all around the crust.

banana cream pie crust crimped and docked

7. Cover with foil or parchment paper and cover with pie weights. In truth, I normally just press the heavy duty foil into the crust and I’ve never needed to use weights. Bake for 10-12 minutes.
8. Remove foil/parchment paper and bake for another 10-12 minutes till golden brown.
9. Cool pie crust.

Pudding ingredients:
4 cups milk
1/2 cup butter
1 1/2 cups sugar (or less, you can taste the pudding later and if it’s not sweet enough, you can add more sugar)
6 heaping Tbsp all-purpose flour
1/2 tsp salt
6 egg yolks
1 tsp vanilla essence

Pudding method:
1. Heat on stove 4 cups milk and 1/2 cup butter over med-low heat in large sauce pan.
2. Mix in another bowl the sugar, flour, salt and yolks. Add to this mixture enough milk from the sauce pan to make a paste.
3. Add paste to milk/butter mixture on stove. Make sure the milk mixture is not too hot when adding the paste or the eggs will curdle. Whisk mixture constantly over med-low heat until the mixture thickens and comes to a boil.
4. Remove from heat immediately and stir in vanilla essence. Let it cool slightly. If you want a smoother pudding, strain it so that the bits of cooked egg will be strained out.

banana cream pie custard

To assemble banana cream pie:
1. Slice 5-8 bananas (depending on size of bananas) in half length-wise. You can choose to slice them into rounds but I find that the pie slices hold better when you slice in half and lay them in circles around the crust. Cut as needed to fit all the bananas into the bottom of the pie crust.

banana cream pie bananas

2. Pour warm pudding over bananas until the bananas are covered and the pudding is almost at the top of the crust.

banana cream pie bananas and custard

3. Cool in refrigerator until set, about 2-3 hours.
4. Just before serving, whip some heavy cream (about 1/2-1 cup depending on how much whipped cream you like), with 2 Tbsp sugar and 1/2 tsp vanilla. Spread whipped cream over pie.

banana cream pie spreading whipped cream

5. Slice into wedges and enjoy!

Cheers, Annie

banana cream pie slice

22 thoughts on “Banana Cream Pie Recipe”

  1. >I was wondering how cool it must be to be able to make this pie with the availability of different bananas then what we have here. Looks terrific.

  2. >I was wondering what all those questions : "Do you like pie crust, bananas, custard and cream?" was all about. Now I see the picture.

  3. >Your banana cream pie looks divine (:

    May I know the size of your pie pan? I'm guessing it's 8"-9"?

    And just a suggestion; you could try mashing a couple of bananas and stirring them into the pudding (while cooling).

    It gave my banana cream pie a lot more body and texture, although I should first warn you that the pudding becomes susceptible to oxidation (so your pie could turn dark yellow after a day or two – eew, I know). But I doubt that'd happen in your case, given the overwhelming response 😉

  4. >Too funny! I just had banana cream pie, too. But mine was only from Marie Callendar. Not nearly as wonderful as a homemade one that you guys created. This one is a total beaut!

  5. >Banana Cream Pie is my favorite! I can't wait to make it, and I'll probably end up having the entire thing all to myself.

  6. >@all – thanks for your comments!

    @Bob – we're loving the fact that we can get so many different kinds of bananas here. No end to the possibilities!

    @Deb – we can send you a postcard! 😉

    @Zue – thanks!

    @BorneoBoy – it goes well with coffee 😉

    @Kong-Kay – hah! we'll make one for you and your family soon, 'kay?

    @Babe_KL – yes, please do!

    @Yamuro – it's a 9" pan.

    the addition of mashed banana in the custard is intriguing. I wonder if using banana extract to flavor the custard would get around the browning problem. But you're right – the pie wouldn't last long enough to brown anyway!

    @Carolyn – thanks! I think that whipping your own cream makes a world of difference.

    @Tasty Eats – sorry, all gone 😉 Gotta make it yourself!

    @Janice – make sure you share!

    @Natalie – thanks!

  7. >Hi Annie,
    This looks great! I was just thinking of having some banana pie and saw this! It's easy for me to get bananas here and I'm definitely going for this!

    BTW, just made your cream scones (I used yogurt again) after so many years and my gf loves it too!

  8. >@Blessed – I saw that you made it. It looks great! Too bad the other members of your family didn't like it. Try again next year; they might change their minds!

    @Nurit – thank you so much for the tweet! You're so sweet. 😉

    @Cakespy – thanks!

  9. >oh my goodness…that pie looks soo good right now. im not home right now but im leaving as soon as i leave this comment so i can go home and eat a HUGE slice of pie! it wont be banana cream pie, but i'll just try imagining it as one hahaha.

    we miss you guys lots!


  10. >Thank-You for yourBanana Cream Pie recipe, made my first pie with my niece for the ThanksGiving weekend. Everyone loved the favor.

  11. >@Theo – hey, miss you guys too!

    @Truman – awesome job! Thanks for posting that.

    @Fkitten – you're welcome!

    @Pinkbop – too cute! I'm very happy that you and your Auntie baked our pie together.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *